Notes from Jan

Sermongate

July 14, 2021

Well, that’s a new one, since I come from a region notorious for Spy-gate and Deflate-gate. But that’s sports, this isn’t. As one who is concerned about The Church today, “Sermongate” by Ruth Graham in the New York Times, grabbed my attention.

According to the article, some preachers lift material from other preachers, then preach it as theirs. As one who’s heard many a sermon, I’m pretty sure a fair number could’ve used some outside help. Mine, too. But outside help isn’t the point.

Maybe some of it falls on the shoulders of those of us who fill the pews. We expect so much of pastors and priests. They’re to be counselors, fund-raisers, community bridge-builders and peacekeepers. Ministers must be skilled at marrying and burying, model perfect families and stellar marriages. And most important, create a rousing sermon, fit for publication week after week. Oh, and often underpaid and understaffed, if at all.

But the ones mentioned in Graham’s article aren’t struggling alone in some small church. They made the big time with a little help from their friends. “One of them, after being congratulated on a strong sermon, offered an aside to an on-line service, like Sermon Central and Logos, ‘Thanks for making me look good.’ “

And that, for me, is the heart of the problem within too much of The Church and the likes of me. We want to look good without being good. Truth matters less than how we appear or than our personal or tribe’s belief system. Alas, truth’s suspect, undervalued and debatable in more than politics. One of the Southern Baptist preachers, Adrian Rogers, didn’t think it was all that bad to use material from another preacher. His view? “If my bullet fits your gun, shoot it, but use your own powder.” Frightening analogy.

Here’s an idea. If it’s late Saturday night and there’s nothing left in the tank, haul out The Sermon on the Mount. (Matthew 5) It’s short, to the point and it’ll preach. And while free for the taking, it’s costly to deliver.

Just ask Jesus.

P.S. I wrote this with a deep awareness of my own sloppy, lazy, cheating bent and an apology to all the faithful men and women who wrestle with texts, hunt illustrations, give credit for outside sources and invite God’s Spirit to bless their words for the sake of the hungry sheep they love.

And, as one of your balky, bruised but blessed sheep, thank you for tending me with and without words. Your hard, creative work to stay connected during the pandemic’s kept me and many others from losing hope. And come Saturday or sooner, may God bless you with a fresh “word from the Lord” for the next time you’re called upon to teach, preach, fill-in or share The Truth, especially when most of us prefer to feel good more than to be or do good.

This story has been viewed 45 times

0 Be the first to HEART this story

6 Comments

  • Reply Carolyn Sylvester July 14, 2021 at 3:18 pm

    Well, since there’s nothing new under the sun, I’m thinking thoughts HAVE to get repeated from time to time.

    • Reply Jan Carlberg July 14, 2021 at 3:40 pm

      And they do, dear Carolyn…and that’s the truth. But there’s also deliberate choosing to “borrow” with the intent of making it look like it originated with you. That’s an act we must be careful to avoid . To share the source is a benefit to all,, like offering hearers and readers a dipper-full, then pointing them to the well.

  • Reply Dan Russ July 15, 2021 at 6:00 am

    A Young Life leader once said that the problem with too many churches is that the pastor’s study has become his office.

    Thanks as always, Jan.

    • Reply Jan Carlberg July 15, 2021 at 10:52 am

      So good to hear from you, dear Dan. Alas, I fear that is too true. Some of this shift rests on our expectations, as well as a slide towards the wrong models of success. While thinking about the Sermon on the Mount and what it looks like to be part of God’s Kingdom , I came across this quote from N.T. Wright. “The whole point of the Kingdom of God is Jesus has come to bear witness to the TRUE TRUTH, which is nonviolent. When God wants to take charge of the world, he doesn’t send in the tanks. He sends in the poor and the meek.” Hope you and Kathy are doing well in Colorado.

      • Reply Wendy July 16, 2021 at 4:54 pm

        Oh my, my head must be in the sand. I hadn’t heard about this problem (and I do think it’s a problem) Ok to share someone else’s thoughts but please give credit. Loved your wonderful idea of preaching the sermon on the mount if the Lord didn’t give anything else. It’s just got to be all about Him!

        • Reply Jan Carlberg July 16, 2021 at 9:08 pm

          Always love hearing from you, dear Wendy. We need to look for ways to cheer each other on to be and do our best, for Christ’s sake, and for disillusioned, skeptical onlookers.

    Share Your Thoughts

    %d bloggers like this: